Maple Leafs 2027 1st Rounder Continues to Rise; It’s Time for the League to Step In and Decide: Flyers or Bruins?

· Yahoo Sports

IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

For all intents and purposes, the Toronto Maple Leafs traded the same first-round draft pick twice at the 2025 NHL Trade Deadline.

Visit saltysenoritaaz.com for more information.

Two trade deadlines ago, the Maple Leafs were in the hunt and were wheeling and dealing, trying to push their roster over the edge for a run at the Stanley Cup. It started by trading their 2027 First-round pick, top-10 protected, to the Philadelphia Flyers, alongside Nikita Grebenkin, in exchange for center Scott Laughton. Then, as a buzzer-beater at the deadline, they traded their 2026 first-rounder, top-5 protected, along with prospect Fraser Minten, to the Boston Bruins for defenseman Brandon Carlo.

At the time, everything seemed fine. But the 2026 NHL Draft Lottery has sent the league into a bit of a spiral. The Maple Leafs won the lottery, selecting 1st overall in the 2026 NHL Draft, which fell under protection. The problem? Both the Flyers and Bruins feel entitled to the Leafs 2027 first-rounder, which currently has the 4th-best odds at the top pick.

If the Leafs’ pick somehow falls outside of the top-10, it becomes easy: the Flyers receive that pick. However, if it falls inside of the protection, then things can get murky.

Should the Flyers be entitled to the pick since their trade was completed first? Or should the Bruins receive the 2027 pick because they received the earlier 2026 draft pick?

Before the 2026 NHL Draft Lottery, we wrote what our friends at Puckpedia had reported: if the Leafs’ 2026 pick is protected, then they would have to choose who receives the 2027 pick if it’s inside the top 10.

On Sportsnet’s Saturday night headlines, NHL insider Elliotte Friedman shared the same thing. “If it is in the top 10, as it stands now, Toronto chooses which team gets it, and the other team would get the unprotected 2028 first.”

“We’ve been trying to get some clarity from the league,” Friedman added. “Does this stand? Is this the way it’s actually going to go? And the answer is yes. In the eyes of the NHL, the way that the trade information is put together, it’s quite clear that it’s Toronto’s choice. So the Maple Leafs do have the option of which team to pick.”

That is going to create a tricky scenario to navigate for the Flyers and the Bruins. It’s time for the league to step in.

The NHL Needs to Step in and Force a Decision, Sooner Rather than Later

On Saturday night headlines, Friedman brought up the possibility of the Maple Leafs trying to squeeze some extra value for their draft pick. “Can [The Maple Leafs] go to the Bruins and the Flyers and say, ‘Do you want one of these two, and what are you willing to consider for us to pick you?'”

Now, that sounds like it’s extortion. To a degree, it is. But Friedman says that it’s possible. “It’d have to be part of a bona fide trade. If it’s an actual bona fide trade that one of those two would make with the Maple Leafs involving other pieces, then yes, that could happen. The league still has to approve any deal, but Toronto can try to leverage it.”

That is exactly why the league has to step in.

I am of the opinion that the Maple Leafs should not be able to benefit from the fact that they made two bad trades. They traded two first-round picks in a year when they were good, not expecting to be this bad so soon. In no world should the Maple Leafs be able to backtrack and say, ‘Give us more, and we’ll consider giving you the pick.’

A team should not be able to extort others simply because the league allowed them to trade the same pick twice.

To me, it goes beyond the potential extortion reasons.

The Bruins are looking to bolster their roster for a run at a Stanley Cup this season. While the Flyers may not be cup hunting, they could certainly use that pick to upgrade their roster and get out of their skid. It’s a valuable asset.

With the lack of clarity on who is the rightful owner of that pick, no team is going to want to trade for said asset until it’s known what year the pick will be in. It’s looking like a prime pick for 2027, but who knows what 2028 will look like?

The sooner the league steps in to make a decision, the better. Who do you think should get the Maple Leafs 2027 first-rounder: the Flyers or the Bruins?

Read More: Flyers Postgame Blog: Philly Survives Risky Decision That Almost Cost the Game

Read more at Philly Hockey Now

Read full story at source