Maple Leafs trading for Adam Fox is an idea with 2 sides to the coin
· Yahoo Sports
Maple Leafs trading for Adam Fox is an idea with 2 sides to the coin originally appeared on The Sporting News. Add The Sporting News as a Preferred Source by clicking here.
Visit biznow.biz for more information.
The Toronto Maple Leafs have to figure out exactly who they are.
Are they a team that is going to immediately vault back into contention? Or is there some serious work needed to dig out of the mess that was the 2025-26 season?
That determines in large part how new front office leaders John Chayka and Mats Sundin approach this offseason.
It determines whether they go after talented but expensive players like New York Rangers defenseman Adam Fox, or not.
The Maple Leafs could clearly use upgrades along the blue line, but Fox wouldn't come cheap, either in his contract or in the cost it might take to get the Rangers to give him up.
Daily Faceoff's Matt Larkin acknowledges all this in a new article in which he lists Fox as a "win-now" solution to the Toronto defense problems. How badly do the Leafs want to win immediately, and would Fox actually make them capable of that?
"On one hand, Fox is exactly what the Leafs need," Larkin writes. "He’s an elite play-driving defenseman, one of the best of his generation, and despite the antiquated criticisms about his intensity, he’d be a transformative addition. On the other hand: he’s 28, has three seasons remaining on his contract and would carry a significant acquisition cost. Fox only makes sense if Chayka and the Leafs truly think 2025-26 was an aberration and that they’ll return to high-end contender status next season. But few of us believe that’s the case, right? The Leafs were just bad this season, with or without their poor injury luck."
MORE: Mitch Marner is making the Maple Leafs miserable
The other problem here is Morgan Rielly, a player the Maple Leafs may trade elsewhere this offseason. Rielly may have been miscast at this stage trying to lead Toronto's defense, but subtracting him is still notable. But without trading Rielly, the Maple Leafs may not be able to afford a different expensive defenseman.
Toronto has lots that it can try to accomplish this offseason, but it's not all easy or simple. Fox is just one example of the competing factors that could end up being at play here.